top of page
Search

Blyth's Reed Warbler

tg42lowcarbonbirding
31 minutes ago
4 min read
Not sure whether he's saying "TA-DAAA" or he's slightly miffed at his predicament
Not sure whether he's saying "TA-DAAA" or he's slightly miffed at his predicament

Early morning was lacklustre – characterised by Andy on our WhatsApp as “like a morgue”. Like most of the autumn so far. I was just pottering about the fields and hedges, more in hope than expectation when Phil called to say an unstreaked acro-type with a long bill had found its way into a net. I arrived at the nets shortly after and the bird was removed from its resting place in the bag.


It looked 'interesting'. Birds up close often present a different kind of identification challenge to birds in the field. It’s unusual for most birders to see 'acros' in the hand and it can be quite confounding. The bird made a couple of calls in the hand, which the ringers likened to how a Reed Warbler calls in the hand… but what do Marsh or Blyth’s Reed call like in the hand? We shouldn’t read too much into that. As the bird was processed by Mick, it was a chance for Andy, Phil and I to get a good look at the bird from different angles and to study some of the important features.


Initially, the thing I noticed the most was that the bird lacked rufous tones, notably on the rump, being a duller olive-grey shade. If you viewed the bird from more than a few feet away, the olive tones became subdued and the bird took on a plainer grey-brown hue. This moved the ID away from Reed Warbler and perhaps suggested Blyth’s Reed Warbler. We looked at the wing and the exposed primaries and they looked on the short side for Reed and were definitely short for Marsh, and lacked any obvious pale tips, plus the bill looked too long and facial expression was off for Marsh. The flanks of the bird were rather grey-toned instead of the warm brown or buff of Marsh and Reed, and the underparts were strikingly white, especially the undertail coverts.


Note the bland grey-brown appearance, lacking any warmth, notably so on the rump
Note the bland grey-brown appearance, lacking any warmth, notably so on the rump
Note the grey flanks and the overall grey-brown tones.
Note the grey flanks and the overall grey-brown tones.

By now, with the general tones, the shorter than expected wing and the long-looking bill, the ID was moving towards Blyth’s Reed. I checked the closed wing and it was uniform and bronze. The tertial edges lacked contrast but the bronze tones contrasted sharply with the rest of the bird. The supercilium was prominent in front of the eye and extended very lightly behind it and the sloping forehead gave the bird a very ‘snouty’ look – again a good Blyth’s feature.


Note the snouty look, the supercilium extending just beyond the eye, the grey-brown upperparts, the bronze tone and homogenous look of the shortish wing, and the rather pale underparts.
Note the snouty look, the supercilium extending just beyond the eye, the grey-brown upperparts, the bronze tone and homogenous look of the shortish wing, and the rather pale underparts.
Note the full, and very white undertail coverts.
Note the full, and very white undertail coverts.

The most important feature though – as I tried to recall – is the wing formula. I knew that the number and position of emarginated primaries were crucial so we took some shots of the open wing. There were clear emarginations on P3 and P4, while the tip of P2 looked to fall around the tip of P6 and P7. The bird released and flew a short distance into some rank vegetation, where it called a few times – a hardish tak or chak – before disappearing. This was all looking very promising for Blyth’s Reed but we wanted to be belt and braces. Andy and I both went home to double check a few things in the books. Upon seeing the wings on a larger screen, it was quickly apparent that the features were an excellent fit for Blyth’s Reed. I ran the pix past a couple of people whose opinion I valued and they both suggested Blyth’s Reed. I then spoke to Andy who confirmed that he had come to the same conclusions that I had.


Note the short tip of P2 falling roughly equal to P6/7 (Reed and Marsh have longer P2) and the emarginations on P3 and P4. There is also a slight emargination present on P5 if you look carefully
Note the short tip of P2 falling roughly equal to P6/7 (Reed and Marsh have longer P2) and the emarginations on P3 and P4. There is also a slight emargination present on P5 if you look carefully

Note the three ringed emarginations on P3,4 and 5. Reed and Marsh only show emarginations on P3.
Note the three ringed emarginations on P3,4 and 5. Reed and Marsh only show emarginations on P3.

Finally, I annotated a couple of the pics to show the diagnostic emarginations and P2 length and put them on our WhatsApp with a few reference photos and returned to the ringers with the good news. Mick said he would send a feather shed during ringing off for DNA analysis, which I initially thought was a bit over the top but the spectre of hybridisation was something we had to contend with so it seemed like a good idea on reflection.


Happily, the DNA came back as a good dumetorum, thanks to Doc Martin and Co. And we discovered that a slightly miffed Blyth’s Reed being handled by humans can make a noise quite like a Reed Warbler! Blyth’s Reed Warblers are tricky birds to ID but they do give a distinctive impression, being short-winged, dull and greyish, with a bronze wing-panel and plain tertials that give the whole closed wing a rather boring look. They are usually very pale below, especially on the undertail coverts and the head and bill have a very jizzy feel to them, once you have your eye in. The species recently bred in the UK for the first time and has been expanding its range westwards across Europe as we have warmed up over the last 20+ years. We will highly likely see more in the near future.



This is the third Blyth’s Reed for TG42, the other two being singing birds in spring 2024 at both Winterton and then Sea Palling.

 
 
 

Comments


TG42 Low Carbon Birding

©2023 by TG42 Low Carbon Birding. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page